Welcome to Carmelo's Pizza and Italian Ice
Carmelo's Pizza and Italian Ice, located in Boyertown, PA, is a culinary gem that brings a delightful blend of classic Italian flavors and innovative pizza creations. The welcoming atmosphere is matched by a menu filled with enticing options, from flavorful sandwiches to unique pizzas like the "upside down pepperoni," praised for its perfect crust and balance of sweetness and heat. Customers frequently rave about the cleanliness and friendly service, making it a beloved spot for families who return weekly. With a commitment to quality and creativity, Carmelo's is rapidly becoming a local favorite for both pizza lovers and Italian ice enthusiasts.
Carmelo's Pizza and Italian Ice: Reviews & Ratings
Love this spot! So many options and creative combos on pizza. Sandwiches are awesome as well
One of my favorite pizza shops around. Had this Sicilian pizza yesterday. It was very good. When I bit in there was a crunch and I find that very exciting, no flop! Anyway I eat pizza here all the time. Clean, friendly, gets better all the time. Boyertown has a new favorite place
All of their food is amazing! They have the best pizza my son has ever eaten. The restaurant is always very clean and everyone is so kind. We eat there at least once a week!
Tried the "upside down pepperoni". Thought it was really exceptional. Unique blend of sweet and hot with a perfectly matched hearty crust. I'd highly recommend trying it.
My family used to have a rule about pizzerias, “If the bathrooms are bad, then the pizza is probably really good.” This restaurant, before being taken in by new owners, was the first instance of this rule applying. However, since the renovation, this place has become an exception. The bathrooms are nice and the pizza is good. The rest of the place looked very clean and fancy, leaning sort of to the Italian style. The food was good and the fries were amazing. Definitely an interesting choice of options, being pizza and water ice, especially after “Mike’s Butchered Meats and Water Ice” where Asad’s now stands. Overall, great place, and while I do prefer Mike’s pizza in Pottstown, this place is a close second.
The pepperoni and hot honey pizza was fantastic. The staff took the time to explain each pizza that was available on the spot. The atmosphere was welcoming and clean. We can't wait to come back. This establishment is a welcome addition to the Boyertown area.
First experience since it's been under new management. The food was great, prices were fair, and the renovations made the place look clean and inviting. We had a chicken cheesesteak and a regular cheesesteak with cooper sharp and they didn't disappoint! We will be going back or ordering delivery next time!
Chef Darvi was at the pizza oven today. My wife and I were in town and stopped in to experience the restaurant update and new ownership. The Chef had some beautiful pies to choose from. We chose the Grand Ma’s Pizza to eat there, then took the rest of the pie home. Great crust, perfect ratio of sauce to cheese, seasoned and flavored to perfection. Chef ‘D’ was so friendly and helpful. The restaurant is such a nice environment . Even the railroad put on a show for us. Thanks for a nice lunch experience. Great menu, can’t wait for our next experience.
Location
-
116 E Philadelphia Ave, Boyertown, PA 19512, United States Hotline: +1 610-367-1900
Welcome to the vibrant world of Carmelo's Pizza and Italian Ice, located in the heart of Boyertown, Pennsylvania. This beloved establishment at 116 E Philadelphia Ave has carved out its niche as a go-to destination for pizza lovers and dessert enthusiasts alike. With a warm, inviting atmosphere and a commitment to quality, Carmelo's has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors.
As you step inside, you're greeted by a tempting array of options that can satisfy even the most discerning palates. The pizza here is nothing short of exceptional, boasting creative combinations that are as delightful for the taste buds as they are for the eyes. Customers rave about the Sicilian pizza, with its satisfyingly crunchy crust that promises no flop and a thrilling bite every time. There’s a particular standout—the "upside down pepperoni"—celebrated for its unique blend of sweet and spicy flavors, perfectly complementing a robust, hearty crust.
The accolades from reviewers like Lisa McGovern and Don Heller speak volumes about the quality and creativity behind each dish. They highlight not only the pizza but also commend the variety of sandwiches, which perfectly accompany the pies. Families are drawn to Carmelo's for its customer-friendly approach and consistently clean environment, as noted by Ashley Griesser. Regular diners find themselves indulging here weekly, a testament to the comforting, delicious experience that awaits.
Beyond pizza, Carmelo’s adventurous approach includes their delightful Italian Ice, a refreshing treat that perfectly rounds out a meal. This combination of savory and sweet keeps patrons coming back for more, establishing Carmelo's as a unique culinary destination in Boyertown.
In a neighborhood filled with options, Carmelo's distinguishes itself not just through its food but also through its welcoming ambience. As Thomas Rose notes, the establishment has transformed into a clean and inviting space where quality and taste are consistently prioritized. Whether you're a longtime resident or a curious newcomer, Carmelo's Pizza and Italian Ice promises an unforgettable dining experience marked by flavor, creativity, and warmth.